Saturday, August 22, 2015

Critical Analysis of “The Role of Materials in the Language Classroom: Finding the balance”

“Anything which is used to help to teach language learners. Materials can be in the form of a textbook, a workbook, a cassette, A CD-Rom, a video, a photocopied handout, a news paper, a paragraph written on a white board, anything which presents or informs about the language being learned.”
-          Brain Tomlinson,
Material plays an important part in the language learning system.  Jane Crawford in his article “The Role of Materials in the Language Classroom: Finding the balance” writes about the materials that are using to meet up the learners needs.  There are basically three parts of his article, one is introduction, next is preplanned teaching materials-helpful scaffold or deliberating Crutch? And another one is Effective Teaching Materials. Crawford in his second part of his article tells about the different concerns view about using materials in the classroom and in third part he used to talk about the effectiveness of materials. In the second part the question arise that do preplanned materials can meet the needs of the all learners, because all learners have their own learning needs, interest and motivation so their learning needs will different. All the human being is unique so their needs will be unique and different from others. So depending on this issue, if the teacher conduct the class from a preplanned book than the learners will be de motivated and it will hamper the learning environment. Second language acquisition process is different for learners, the entire learner cannot obtain same thing in a certain time they need more or less time. For pre planned materials if the teacher intended to take the class with same materials without assessing the learner’s needs than their purpose and outcome will not be up to the mark. Preplanned course book reduce teachers role in the class and sometimes there will be culturally differences attitude in a pre planned course book or materials, which will have negative effect on the learners because they cannot relate their learning with their real world and fail to contextualize language activities.
According to author materials writer have to be familiar with the teaching and learning style and the context of the materials use otherwise the material will be useless. So the material designer has to be experienced, because they know the critical use of materials in the classroom. With the growing tendency of technological use teachers also have to know the use of technology and their uses. By using the modern technology students will get the opportunity of outer world and it reflects the real world to the students and it grabs the attention of the learners. But if the teacher only follow the text book then all the activity will be more controlled and their will be no feedback or challenges for the learners to improve their own learning. To design a material teacher has to know the answer of the questions is that what is learnt indeed learnable. In the article author tells that teacher’s guide may provide a scaffold for leaner’s to think. In the article the author suggests that participants should get chance to participates so that they can identify where the lesson fits into the wider context of the language program. Hutching and Torres suggestion for this is the text book is important because it allows for negotiation, accountability and orientation.
In Effective teaching materials part the author eight characteristics of effective materials. In a language learning process two component play the main role, one is student and the other one is teacher and the materials bridge them in a tie. So a material has to be effective otherwise the bridge will be broken. The author in this section emphasis on language to develop materials. Language is functional and must be contextualize, because the language is purposeful and for a certain purpose people learn second language. So the materials have to develop concerning their context. So he told that language development requires learner’s engagement in purposeful use. To engage learners more the audio-video materials inclusion will make learners more inter active. They feel interest, so choosing the video and audio materials with the cultural context. Depending on the learner’s background and goals, teacher can decide whether to enhance and reduce this focus. The language use in the materials should be realistic and authentic, to learn language if the teacher use authentic materials then it remains long period in the learners mind. And another remarkable thing is use realistic language, so that it can create easy environment for all proficiency level. Suppose using to correct pronunciation if a teacher use a video which contained 7-8 minutes than the learner will not understand all the words and they feel difficulty so the material will not be authentic. So to make authentic video, it must contain minimum 5 points.  Another point he includes classroom material will usually seek to include an audio visual component and his pint of view is effective teaching materials foster learner’s autonomy. So his emphasis on giving exercise or activities by using multi media. If it can be done then the student will move into a new situation and it creates learning environment. He also gives emphasis on materials flexibility and creates materials depending on individual and contextual differences as well as engage learners both affectively and cognitively. To develop language proficiency one learner should have knowledge on 4 skills.  To make the learner real communicator if the materials cannot provide the opportunity of these four skills development then the aim will not be fulfilled. So the main idea is materials only give the input of certain linguistic and cultural preparation but the main purpose is to attain language by the ultimate learning process.

Materials mainly give the direction to the teachers through which teacher get is idea how to deal with class to get maximum output. Through this article the author tries to give direction of maximum use of materials with certain perspective. With the guideline of the materials learners and teachers can be helpful because it provides input. It is the teacher’s responsibility to use the materials with the needs of the learners by balancing the outcome and context. In a learner centered classroom materials have to be have more learning centered activates and students have to get chance to take part of this activities, than the material become useful.

No comments:

Post a Comment